Since this was my first time reading Pride and Prejudice by
Jane Austen, and my first time watching the 2005 rendition of the book, I
didn’t really know what to expect. Of course I have heard of this book numerous
times and am aware of how well known it is, however, I have never gotten around
to reading it myself or watching the movie. I am not really a huge fan of
period pieces, yet with this movie, I was pleasantly surprised. I was also
surprised at how well the original book and the 2005 movie correlated; all
though there were a few parts in the book that did not show up in the movie. It
is understandable, however, because it is hard to fit a novel with over 60
chapters into just a 2-hour time slot.
In my opinion, I preferred the movie to the book, because for me I felt like the movie was easier to follow. However, the book did live up to the high regards that people gave it. I loved how both Jane and Elizabeth fell in love with their partners, not because of the amount of money they had, even though at the beginning that was a huge part, but because of how each of them felt about one another and how they were deep inside as a person. Knowing that Elizabeth disregarded Mr. Darcy at first because of his attitude and the way he presented himself, even after knowing that he was richer than Mr. Bingley, showed how strong of a person she was and how she knew money wasn’t everything. I did, however, appreciate the fact that they did end up together and fall in love with each other, because it was easy to see that there was a slight connection between the two from the very beginning. Since this book was at first meant to be titled First Impressions, Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy’s relationship showed how first impressions don’t always dictate how everything else will go.
Comparing Pride and Prejudice to today’s world, especially in the United States, I do see a lot of similarities as well as some differences. For example, not all women today marry men only for their wealth and social status, and most women value a man’s attitude and character. However, some women do idolize athletes, celebrities, or men with very high paying jobs and statuses, and there are many cases of young women marrying older men only for their money. Another similarity between Pride and Prejudice and what goes on today is the fact that Mrs. Bennet was so consumed with the idea that she needs to get her children to marry. Many mothers today are interested and constantly meddling in both their daughter and son’s lives about their relationship and why they aren’t married yet, or when they are going to give them grandchildren. Although it’s not always to the extent of forcing them to marry someone, unlike Mrs. Bennet trying to force Elizabeth to marry Mr. Collins and chasing after her when she refuses, it does still happen. Even arranged marriages that happen in other countries are similar to what was talked about in Pride and Prejudice, because some families arrange their daughters to marry a man from a wealthy family.
I did also glance over Pride and Popularity by Jenni James, and I felt that it was an interesting modernization of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice. It goes to show that some of what was mentioned in Jane Austen’s novel can be applied to today’s world and even to a younger generation, although one of the Bennet girls was married at only 15, the majority of the story was focused on the oldest sisters and featured an older crowd. I liked how this book mirrored the ideas of Pride and Prejudice, but replaced wealth with high school popularity. In the very first couple of sentences, three girls, Chloe, Madison, and Alyssa, are having a conversation about a boy who they think is the “hottest guy ever”, and Alyssa responds with “I’ve secretly dreamed of marrying him since I was ten”. This initial conversation sets the pace for the rest of the book and gives an insight to each of the character’s personality. The first chapter was coincidently named First Impressions, which helped relate the two books and show the connections between the Bennet women wanting to marry Mr. Bingley because of his wealth, and these high school girls wanting to marry this boy, known as Taylor Anderson, because of his looks, popularity, and athleticism. The main theme of this story is similar to the rocky start and final relationship of Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy, but it is told through the innocent eyes of Chloe and Taylor. I feel like history always has a way of repeating itself, so I didn’t find it surprising how well Pride and Prejudice could be applied to today and how well Pride and Popularity handled this topic.
Overall, I did enjoy the novel and the movie, and hope to
read some more of her novels in the future.